No time for gutter politics

Yesterday as north Queenslanders were trying to fortify their homes against the pending onslaught of cyclone Yasi, or taking shelter in evacuation centres where they would spend a sleepless night hoping that there would be something left of their town this morning, Tony Abbott released a letter asking for donations to campaign against the government’s flood levy.

Not only is this crass and insensitive, but also reeks of hypocrisy in the extreme.

Let’s make no mistake about this. Abbott’s objection to the flood levy has nothing to do with rebuilding Queensland after the floods last month. It is an attempt to get the national broadband network scrapped and for the government to slash funding to other infrastructure projects so that he can use a projected reduced budget surplus as a political weapon against the government’s economic management.

This is gutter politics at a time when we need our political leaders to rise above partisan differences and lead. But then Tony Abbott is not a leader. He snatched the Liberal leadership from Malcolm Turnbull by a single vote after Turnbull’s support within the party weakened with his trenchant support for the government’s emissions trading scheme.  Then, puffing out his chest, Abbott strutted around the country declaring that “climate change is crap”. Abbott is not a leader, he is a schoolyard bully.

As a minister in the Howard government Abbott supported the imposition of seven different temporary levies (listed at the bottom of this post) imposed on the tax-paying public to fund various expenditures, starting with the gun buyback levy in 1996. How is the flood levy different to Howard’s levies? It’s not. Governments impose extra charges on tax payers as required and the flood levy will amount to less than a cup of coffee a week for most tax payers.

Gillard’s flood levy is not a perfect solution by any means. The devastation that daylight will reveal in north Queensland this morning is certain to run into billions of dollars. An increased frequency in extreme weather events is going to have a huge impact on national infrastructure. Roads, railways, power stations, public buildings, ports, schools, airports – these have all been damaged, in some cases destroyed, over the past month through the floods and now the cyclone. This is the point Abbott seems to have missed. When people make a donation to a recovery fund, their money goes to assisting families rebuild and restart their lives. It helps to replace possessions lost in the flood and put a roof back over people’s heads. The flood levy will assist the state government to rebuild the infrastructure that keeps the state – and the nation – running.

Abbott’s letter is instructive in its last line before the PS asking for money. He invokes the image of ‘hardworking Australians, struggling to meet their own family budgets’. He then asks those same struggling Australians to give him money so that he can ‘campaign’ against the government’s flood levy. So, you can give a couple of dollars a week to the government to help put a chunk of Queensland about the size of France and Germany combined and which provides a considerable amount of your food back on the road to recovery, or, Tony says, you can give him your money so he can stop that from happening.

That this bully came within the width of a cigarette paper from being Prime Minister is truly frightening. If he is acting on the advice of political advisors they should be sacked immediately. If he is acting alone he should be sacked by his party.

Levies imposed by the Howard government with thanks to The Gutter Trash blog:

1996- Gun Levy
1997- Gun Levy
1998- No Levies
1999- Stevedoring Levy
2000- Stevedoring Levy-Milk Levy-East Timor Levy
2001 – Stevedoring Levy-Milk Levy-Ansett Levy
2002- Stevedoring Levy-Milk Levy-Ansett Levy
2003- Stevedoring Levy-Milk Levy-Ansett Levy-Sugar Levy
2004-Stevedoring Levy-Milk Levy-Sugar Levy
2005- Stevedoring Levy-Milk Levy-Sugar Levy
2006- Stevedoring Levy-Milk Levy-Sugar Levy
2007- Milk Levy


About Coffee with Ruby

Ruby is a writer, lecturer and thinker who blogs mostly on politics, environment and social philosophy. She has been at the coalface of the political process, but is now strictly an observer. Join Ruby for coffee and musings over whatever is going on at the time ...
This entry was posted in Blog postings and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to No time for gutter politics

  1. Cyn says:

    He’s not a leader, he ‘snatched’ the leadership when Turnbull’s support in the party weakened?? Gosh, who does THAT sound like?

    It’s not how close Abbot came to leadership that’s frightening, it’s the fact that Gillard did.

    The people of Australia are NOT happy about the flood levy. What did you expect? That everything else STOPS when a weather front hits one part of the country?

    I’ll give my money to someone who tells me what he’s doing with it, rather than a government who managed to waste the ’emergency fund’ we had set aside for this very thing that disappeared into nowhere.

    • You’ll give your money to someone who tells you what they’re doing with it? Really? Do you know what the government did with the money you paid to the Timor tax? The milk tax? The Ansett levy? The sugar tax? You paid them all between 1996 and about 2001. The flood levy is not a perfect solution by any means, but that wasn’t my point. My point was that using the flood levy as a political cudgel when people are still shovelling slime, mud and toads out of their kitchens is mean and insensitive. Compounding that by asking them for money to campaign against it is simply crass. As for usurping the leadership, yep, there’s been a bit of that. Sugggest you read Ellis’ “Suddenly Last Winter”, or Cassidy’s “The Party Thieves” for a couple of different perspectives. Thanks for taking the time to read and reply, though.

  2. Beau Gamble says:

    Thanks for the info, Ruby — very interesting.

    What an absolute cold-hearted, nonsensical, hypocritical bastard. Abbott, that is.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s